Could You Be Earning More from Your Consulting Practice? The Data Says Yes.

It’s no secret that many early-stage consultancies leave a lot of money on the table - though it might not feel that way if you’re busy with client work. This is not a guess. This is not my opinion. The data is overwhelming and leaves little doubt: across studies from Hinge Marketing, Consulting Success, BenchPress, and Source Global Research, we find that “average” firms often struggle to break past incremental growth and modest profitability.

Meanwhile, “high-growth” consultancies - those enjoying up to 9x faster growth and 50% higher profit margins - prove that real breakthroughs are possible if you position yourself correctly, price wisely, and engage clients early.

‍

First, let’s clarify the scope of this gap.‍

Many boutique firms (19%, according to BenchPress) rely on a single client for more than half their revenue, putting them in a dangerous spot if that client disappears. Hinge Marketing highlights another recurring issue: smaller firms often lack a clear differentiator, making them one voice in a “sea of sameness.”

Buyers confirm this problem: 40% say consultancies they evaluated didn’t fully grasp their needs, while 32% were uncertain about the exact value they’d receive. When potential clients doubt your ability to deliver ROI, you either get underpaid or overlooked entirely.

Meanwhile, specialization pays off. Research from Consulting Success reveals that specialists consistently earn higher fees than generalists.

Reflection Questions

• Are you relying heavily on one or two major clients instead of a broader, more stable base?
• Does your online presence instantly convey a unique specialty, or could a prospect mistake you for any other “general” consultant?
• When a lead arrives, do you consistently show them concrete value or do they walk away unsure of what they’d be getting?

‍

Then there’s the matter of visibility and credibility - and your pricing decisions.

Hinge’s Inside the Buyer’s Brain research highlights a “visibility gap.” Even when firms deliver excellent work, only 23% of buyers perceive them as having a strong public presence. This is risky because 9 out of 10 buyers conduct online research - Googling your name, checking LinkedIn, reading articles - before deciding to reach out. If they can’t find compelling evidence of your expertise, 8 out of 10 consultants get ruled out right there.

Personal referrals remain powerful - over 70% of buyers begin by asking colleagues for recommendations - but a strong digital footprint is now mandatory. Even the warmest referral will look you up online.

Pricing is just as critical. Consultancy BenchPress 2023 data shows that offering three pricing tiers instead of one doubles the likelihood of achieving a high (>60%) conversion rate. If you rely on basic hourly rates or single-figure quotes, you risk reinforcing a perception that you’re a commodity. This aligns with Source Global Research’s finding of a “value-quality gap”: while 69% of clients say the work delivered is high quality, only 40% feel it clearly exceeded the project’s cost. That 29-point difference suggests many consultancies - possibly including yours - are not capturing fees that reflect the true value they deliver.

Reflection Questions

• When new prospects google your firm or your name, do they see proof of specialized authority, or is there almost nothing there?
• Are you walking buyers through multiple pricing options (perhaps via tiered packages or outcome-based fees), or do they get a single take-it-or-leave-it quote?
• How much of your firm’s content and marketing actually addresses client pains and showcases ROI, vs. generic “we can help anyone” messaging?

‍

Finally, think about timing and relationships.‍

Buyers often juggle multiple stakeholders - Gartner estimates the average number at seven for mid-sized organizations - and each one needs assurance that you understand their unique problems. If you only show up when the RFP hits, you’re missing the chance to guide the conversation.

Inside the Buyer’s Brain research shows that 71% of buyers want advisors to join earlier in the process. They recognize that “they don’t know what they don’t know” and are open to deeper conversations about strategy. Furthermore, once you’ve delivered a small project, it’s 3 to 10 times easier to upsell a higher-ticket engagement. Yet, many small consultancies fail to plan for building on the trust they’ve already earned. They also miss opportunities to proactively reach out to new prospects before the need becomes urgent.

Reflection Questions

• Do you mostly respond to inquiries and RFPs, or do you proactively identify who to help - and contact them before they issue a formal request?
• Once you’ve won a small piece of work, is there a clear path for delivering more value in the future, or do you simply “hope” the client calls again?
• If you had to show exactly how your firm maintains ongoing relationships (status updates, check-ins, insight sharing), would you have a solid system - or nothing formal at all?

‍

Let these takeaways sink in - then look at your own consultancy with fresh eyes.

Chances are, the data rings true: you really could be growing faster and earning more.

When you layer these studies together - Hinge’s data on high-growth differentiation, Consulting Success’s findings on specialist fees, BenchPress’s caution about pricing strategies and referral programs, Source Global’s insights on brand and innovation - one message dominates: boutique consultancies often operate far below their true revenue and profitability potential.

• They undersell themselves by offering minimal pricing choices.
• They wait too long to contact prospective clients or fail to articulate a clear ROI.
• They hide in broad positioning, never forming that strategic advantage a well-defined niche can create.
• They skip marketing or alliances because they’re too busy with client work, ironically jeopardizing their future growth.
• They don’t invest in consistent brand visibility.
• They rarely follow a structured approach to referrals, even though 70% of buyers pick a provider recommended by friends or colleagues.

All these points add up to a big, flashing sign: “Yes, you could be earning more.”

If you suspect you’re leaving business (or bigger margins) on the table, the data suggests you’re right.

‍

Here's the uncomfortable truth:

Recognizing that we’re underperforming is tough. It’s easier to think, “We’re doing fine,” especially if you’re busy with client work. But the numbers don’t lie: smaller consultancies regularly discover they’re well below their potential. Many see a 30% gap in perceived value versus quality. Others rely so heavily on a single client that they risk losing half their revenue overnight.

If you can push past the discomfort, you’ll uncover a massive opportunity to reposition, raise fees, market earlier, strengthen relationships, and create new revenue streams. You don’t have to accept status-quo growth.

So the next time you question whether your consulting practice could be pulling in more revenue, consider the evidence. Chances are, the gap is bigger than you think - and the payoff for closing it is worth the effort.

The only question is whether you’ll keep leaving money on the table or start closing those gaps today.